11 March 2005

US Supreme Court - capital punishment and minors

Roper v. Simmons

Fascinating on so many levels:
- the ultimate issue is interesting in its own right
- the question of over-ruling earlier decisions
- the (ambulatory) interpretation of the US Constitution - the reference to International Law (including a Convention which the US hasn't ratified - along with Somalia, the only countries in the world not to).

But I love it more for the language of the dissent and the (dysfunctional?) relationships and interaction between the judges.

No comments:

Post a Comment